How well a method performs
17 min
Skills you'll build3 skills
- Calculate a sigma metric with compatible error, bias, and imprecision units
- Tell method agreement from a high correlation coefficient
- Test proficiency samples through the routine patient workflow
At the bench: Check method precision and agreement against acceptance limits
Try first
Get the idea
Daily QC shows whether a method is in control today. Three other tools show whether the method meets its quality requirements and whether it agrees with other methods and laboratories.
The sigma metric
The sigma metric is the number of CVs that fit into the allowable total error remaining after bias:
sigma = (allowable total error % − |bias %|) ÷ CV %
- Bias is taken as an absolute value, regardless of sign, because a method that reads 3% low uses as much of the allowable error as one that reads 3% high.1
- All three numbers must be in the same form. Convert an SD to a CV with CV = SD ÷ mean × 100, and a bias in concentration units to a percent of the same mean, or keep all three in concentration units.
- The metric applies to one concentration and one allowable error, and it is one input to choosing QC rules.
Interpret the metric this way:1
| Sigma metric | What it means for QC |
|---|---|
| Near 6 | Ample margin for error |
| Near 3 | Tighter QC rules, and more of them |
Method agreement
Method agreement comes up when a laboratory compares a new method with the one it replaces. Paired patient specimens are run on both, and the correlation coefficient, r, is often the first number printed.
- A high r shows only that the pairs fall close to a straight line.
- Two methods can fall on a near-perfect line with one reading consistently higher. The value of r mainly shows whether the specimens covered a wide enough range to fit the line well.2
- Agreement is judged from the bias at the concentrations where clinical decisions are made, compared with the bias the laboratory decided in advance it could accept.2,3
Proficiency testing
Proficiency testing (PT) sends blinded samples from an outside program, and the laboratory's answers are graded against a target or a peer group. PT assesses the laboratory's routine error, so the samples go through the routine workflow. Under CLIA they are tested:4
- with the regular patient workload
- by the people who usually run the test
- with the usual method
- the same number of times as a patient specimen
Laboratories must not:4
- discuss PT results with each other before the reporting deadline
- send PT samples to another laboratory for testing they are certified to do themselves
With special handling, the grade reflects that handling and misses the error in patient results.
Follow the bench demonstration
Sources for this step
References
- Westgard QC. Best practices for Westgard rules. Accessed September 23, 2026.
- Westgard JO. The comparison of methods experiment. Westgard QC. Accessed September 23, 2026.
- Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute. Measurement Procedure Comparison and Bias Estimation Using Patient Samples. 3rd ed. CLSI guideline EP09c. Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute; 2018. Accessed September 23, 2026.
- Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. 42 CFR §493.801: Condition: Enrollment and testing of samples. Accessed September 23, 2026.
Watch one
A cholesterol control has a mean of 200 mg/dL and an SD of 4.0 mg/dL.
- A peer comparison shows the method reads 6 mg/dL low at that level.
- The laboratory's allowable total error is 10%.
What is the sigma metric?
- Convert the SD to a CV: 4.0 ÷ 200 × 100 = 2.0%.
Sigma requires imprecision as a percent when the allowable error is a percent.
- Express the bias as a percent of the mean: 6 ÷ 200 × 100 = 3.0%.
Bias must be in the same form as the other two numbers.
- Take the absolute value of the bias, 3.0%, and ignore the sign.
A low bias uses the allowable error just as a high one does.
- Calculate (10 − 3.0) ÷ 2.0 = 7.0 ÷ 2.0 = 3.5.
The remaining allowable error divided by the CV gives the sigma metric.
- Check in mg/dL: the allowance is 20 mg/dL, and (20 − 6) ÷ 4.0 = 3.5.
Working in concentration units must give the same answer if the units match.
Your turn
Use it
Optional for this step.
- The chemistry section is replacing its calcium method. Ten patient specimens were run on the current method (comparative) and the new one (candidate).
- Before the study, the laboratory director set the acceptance criterion: a bias within ±0.12 mg/dL at 8.5 mg/dL and at 10.5 mg/dL.
- The fitted line has r = 0.9997. It predicts a candidate result of 8.60 mg/dL where the comparative method reads 8.5 mg/dL, and 10.65 mg/dL where it reads 10.5 mg/dL.
Only the bias at 10.5 mg/dL falls outside the acceptance criterion. The pairs fit a line closely. At the upper decision concentration the candidate reads 0.15 mg/dL high, beyond the limit set before the study.
Review missed questions
For reference
Sources checked
The rest of this step has a short briefing, a demonstration at the bench, 3 practice problems and a short case.
Free account: keep your progress and get review reminders. Have one? Sign in